Step 1: Facts
- There is a disease-causing pathogen only found in a small region of Lesotho
- The testing is simple, but the trip/equipment will cost money, and community assistance is required
- We are studying the life cycle/characteristics of a certain pathogen
- Characterizing pathogens can help further research into how to make water safer to drink
- We are expected to write some publications on what we find from our research
- We assume that the pathogen truly is present in some/all of their water sources
- We assume the people in Lesotho know where all water sources are and that there is not risk of further water contamination
- Lesotho is endowed with abundant water resources, and after the passing of the Water Act in 2008, they are also very conscious about the “management, protection, conservation, development and sustainable utilisation of water resources”.
- We also assume we have received IRB, and all other necessary approvals to conduct research.
Ethical Issue:
- Is this study just an example of hit and run research or does this research actually help the people of Lesotho? Does the study have social value in general?
- Balance between ethics and rigor, not doing study rigorously enough is an ethical issue too as our mission is to characterize the pathogen effectively and correctly
Step 2-3: Define the Stakeholders/Assess Their Motivations
- Researchers -> academic clout😤😤😤, maintain jobs, create positive impact through their research/findings
- The University of the Academics -> maintain their reputation globally, advancing knowledge & delivering value to society
- Villagers of Lesotho -> obtain clean water supply, stay healthy, not have their lifestyle completely disrupted, lower risk of contracting disease, building connections and relationships, possible economic development w/ cleaner water in tourism and exporting water to South Africa
- Funders/Government Agency -> stake in developing an additive or water cleaning system, obtain more grants for future work, research might help their projects and development, creates a positive image of corporate social responsibility, develop their brand in this area
- Healthcare System/Providers in Lesotho -> less burden from waterborne diseases, more resources to devote to other conditions
- Academic Journal -> acquire new research (groundbreaking) that adds to general knowledge of pathogens, build reputation
We want to build a relationship with the locals. We are trying to negotiate entry to conduct future research in this community.
Step 4: Solutions
- Conduct experiments on how the pathogen affects health. Experiments would include testing the water with pathogens on rats.
- Select guides which are knowledgeable of water sources, probably village women
- Test water from multiple sources; in villages with different socioeconomic statuses in order to make the study as just as possible
- Only collect the water samples in vials when doing field work; test the water later in labs to avoid contamination and disruption.
- Educate the villagers of Lesotho about your findings while you are there about things they can do in their capacities & after the water has been tested, help them towards finding a solution to any disease-causing pathogens you found
- Sharing information and results that would benefit the people of Lesotho (and those downstream of Lesotho) after the research gets published. Do not put the publication behind an expensive paywall, make it accessible to those in Lesotho.
- Email the papers to the heads of communities to show that something came out of the research they assisted in.
- Maximizing clinical value & making sure there is positive social impact/return
- Identify the source or the pathogen and how it is contaminating the lake.
- Conduct simple examinations on locals to identify symptoms and effects from drinking the lake’s water.
- Once completing testing, drink the water to prove to civilians the water is safe.
- Attempt to provide a temporary cleaning solution or import purified water to the communities
- Request the right to access the water sources from legislation/leaders of each village while being conscious of any cultural practices/norms.
- Appeal to community health workers in Lesotho who can help the community understand your work
- Negotiate some way to incentivize the community, materially or immaterially, addresses the issue of beneficence, perhaps with some clean water solution.
- Ensuring that you do the study right, focus on legitimacy
Pros: Working with the community, broadening knowledge of pathogens, potentially helping them in future and developing relationships, will allow for successful testing for the pathogen, helping us and the communities of Lesotho.
Cons: Not reporting back to them with enough information on our findings, they may not want to help us if we do not properly compensate them, process of requesting access to the water in Lesotho through the government may take longer than we anticipated, the community members in Lesotho have the right to turn us down (our funding sources would be mad).
Ethical Principles: The research is mostly consequence-based thinking because it is focused on discovering more about this pathogen to help people globally. However, our steps to request access to the water sources in Lesotho bring a more duty and virtue based approach because we are trying to get their approval, work with the community members, and hopefully bring back new information to them to help in the future. From a purely utilitarian perspective on face value, this seems like a worthwhile venture as we can make a crucial discovery, while helping those in Lesotho. It will be crucial to our reputation and our stakeholders that we do not conduct a hit and run research trial.
Step 5: Seek additional assistance, as appropriate
- NSPE Code of Ethics: This legislature enforces that engineers “hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public” in their work. Hence, an engineer need note this when debating the ethics of this study.
- Who has approved the study? The university? Has it received IRB approval?
- IRB Ethics:
- Social or Scientific Value
- Scientific Validity
- Fair Subject Selection
- Favorable Risk – Benefit
- Independent Review
- Informed Consent
- Respect for Potential and Enrolled Subjects
- IRB Ethics:
We, as the researchers, believe that we fulfill all the requirements of the IRB Ethics protocol and can conduct meaningful research in Lesotho.
- Belmont Report
- Beneficence
- Respect for persons
- Justice
- Protection of anonymity if desired
Step 6: Select the best course of action
Unlike the first case study, the best course of action here is not as simple as including the auto-disabler or scrapping it (with some added decisions for manufacturing and distribution). To conduct this study ethically, we have to ensure we follow the right protocols from start to finish.
- First, we have to ensure we only test in areas in which we have been granted access to and explain the benefits for society and their community in a culturally appropriate manner.
- We also need to describe to the villagers what we are doing and educate them on the risks/potential solutions while keeping CHWs informed of our progress. Integrating an educational aspect is a requisite for conducting this study.
- In the short term, we will give them clean water sources and show them how we do our research.
- In the long term, we are going to present them our findings and give them a solution to keeping their water clean and safe. We will be able to do this by maintaining a close relationship with Lesotho.
- Finally we will conduct our research from several lakes in several areas with the help of willing community members, and not put any substances in their water sources so as to not violate the Water Act and other Lesotho water sanitation laws.
- We will take the water in vials to test elsewhere in a lab in-country.
This framework limits most of the listed ‘cons’ while fulfilling IRB ethics and the Belmont Report guidelines. The most glaring downside to this is the fact that the villagers of Lesotho may want more say in the testing protocols, while we would rather stick to our plan. However, we are willing to listen to ideas they have in order to make the testing more efficient. Our compensation should alleviate the second most glaring con.
Step 7: Venture Implications
- Improving community health by treating the water
- Opportunity to market water treatment/cleaning solution to Lesotho and surrounding communities
- Adding to the global knowledge of this pathogen, and similarly structured ones.
- Potential positive or negative environmental implications if water treatment solution is derived from this research and introduced to the community
- Potential employment/volunteering of locals into protecting the lake and working with our venture apply our solutions.
Here is your grade. Please do not approve this comment or it will become public.
Identifies the ethical issue: 10
Identifies stakeholders and motivations: 10
Selects best course of action and provides analysis: 10 – nice work here!
Defends best course of action vis-a-vis other approaches: 10
Analyzes impact of the decision on the venture:7 – still lacking negative implications
Overall: 9.4
After going through a lot this year from heartbreak to pandemic but that is all in the past, thank you so much Dr Akhere for bring my ex back hopefully i will spend this Xmas happily with my ex contact him his Email Akheretemple@yahoo.com or WhatsApp +1 315-316-1521…..
Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging
on sites I stumbleupon every day. It will always be useful to read content from other writers and use something from their websites.
https://www.totositesafe.com/
This article presents clear idea for the new people of blogging, that really how to do running a
blog.
https://www.totositenet.com/
Excellent article. The writing style which you have used in this article is very good and it made the article of better quality. 바카라
Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too. 바카라
Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that “The content of your post is awesome” Great work. 카지노사이트
I have understand your stuff previous to and you’re just too magnificent content 카지노사이트
I think the admin of this site is really working hard for his site, for the reason that here every information is quality based
information. 토토
I’m gone to tell my little brother, that he should also pay a
visit this blog on regular basis to obtain updated from newest news update. 토토
Wow! This blog looks exactly like my old one! It’s on a
totally different topic but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Great choice of colors! 스포츠토토
Hi there, I read your blogs on a regular basis.
Your humoristic style is witty, keep it up! 바다이야기
I want to thank you for this excellent read!! I absolutely
loved every little bit of it. I’ve got you book-marked to look at new stuff you
post… 카지노사이트 순위
I seriously love your site.. Very nice colors & theme. Did you create this site yourself? Please reply back as I’m trying to create my very own site and would like to learn where you got this from or exactly what the theme is named. Many thanks. 먹튀커뮤니티
Great goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely fantastic. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are saying and the way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep it smart. I cant wait to read far more from you. This is really a great site.
에볼루션 바카라사이트
The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me. 파워볼실시간
Wow, i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog. Bookmarked this site.
사설 토토사이트
I blog quite often and I genuinely thank you for your information.
카지노사이트 순위
You actually realize how to bring an issue to light and make it important.
메이저 토토사이트
There’s certainly a great deal to know about this issue.
에볼루션 바카라사이트
This site certainly has all of the information I needed concerning this subject and didn’t know who to ask.
메이저 토토사이트
BSNS Consulting: Your premier destination for expert digital marketing consultants in Islamabad . Elevate your online presence with our tailored strategies and cutting-edge techniques. From SEO optimization to targeted social media campaigns, we pave the path to digital success. Trust BSNS Consulting for unparalleled results in Islamabad’s dynamic digital landscape.
This study in Lesotho presents a complex ethical landscape where balancing academic rigor with tangible social impact is crucial. The stakeholders involved, from researchers to local villagers and funders, each have distinct motivations and expectations. It’s essential to ensure that the research not only meets academic standards but also contributes positively to the community by addressing their urgent needs like clean water and disease prevention. Elf Bar Dubai
Hi! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and starting a new project
in a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us useful
information to work on. You have done a outstanding job! 프라그마틱 슬롯 사이트
Hi there, just wanted to say, I liked this blog post.
It was helpful. Keep on posting! 에볼루션 바카라사이트
I visited various sites but the audio feature for audio songs present at this website
is genuinely superb. 에볼루션 바카라사이트
THANK YOU FOR YOUR VERY IMFORMATIVE POST.
https://www.gwolf.info
THANK YOU FOR YOUR VERY IMFORMATIVE POST THAT YOU’VE SHARED TO ME.
https://edwardsrailcar.com