Problem Statement: Jack is an American student who lived at a youth center in Kenya while working on a social venture. In this role, he lived and interacted with the children at the center and worked closely with the staff. One Saturday evening, kids under the age of 14 years were to receive presents that were sent by an international donor organization. A staff member at the youth center had picked up all the gifts the previous weekend and they were finally going to be distributed this Saturday. When it came time to give the gifts out after dinner, the staff members called Jack up to the front – as he was a guest – to assist in the gift-giving ceremony. The staff members had allocated the gifts for the children and labelled them – Jack’s job was to hand out the gifts to the kids. The only problem was that four children did not receive gifts and the staff members did not appear to be concerned about the four forgotten children. As kids began leaving the hall, they thanked Jack for the gifts. The kids were convinced that Jack had gotten the gifts for them. Jack felt a little awkward but at the same time reflected that a good relationship with the kids would help him in several ways during his five-month stay at the center.
At the bottom of the boxes containing the gifts, there were a few black hats. The kids that did not get a present were brought over to the box and given a hat. However, they were upset about the fact that they were not given the hat as ceremoniously as the other kids. The staff gave them their hat and shooed them on their way as if they had some fault in this situation. As one of the little boys who did not receive a gift left the hall, he walked past Jack holding his black hat, and gave him a stare that clearly indicated that he blamed Jack for not receiving a gift. Jack met with the staff and discussed how the four kids were very upset and felt ‘left out’ after the incident. The staff did not acknowledge the problem and were a little piqued that they were being blamed for such a trivial matter. They were convinced that Jack was making a big deal out of the situation and were concerned that Jack would become a ‘children’s rights activist’ and create unnecessary problems for them. The only response they gave Jack was – “If you think there is a problem, then you go ahead and solve it”. If you were Jack, how would you proceed?
Step 1: Determine the facts in the situation – obtain all of the unbiased facts possible. Clearly state the ethical issue.
- Jack, an American student, is a guest at a youth center in Kenya that is helping in giving out gifts during the ceremony
- Kids in the youth center are expecting gifts, the left out kids believe they are equally deserving of gifts
- Four children did not receive gifts, and with their level of maturity at this age, it is assumed that they will not be able to realize that it was a mistake.
- After the staff distributed the black hats, they did not further respond to the children who we assume are still upset from not receiving gifts.
- The kids blamed Jack for not getting gifts, even though the staff allocated the donated gifts.
- Jack discussed with the staff the kids felt upset and left out, but they didn’t acknowledge the problem at all and believed it was Jack’s problem
- Jack wants to accommodate the kids who did not receive gifts, but this may be a part of Kenyan, or the youth center’s culture, where some kids do not receive gifts.
- It is assumed that the black hat is not as good, or as special of a present as the other gifts
When Jack told the staff the children were disappointed, they did not seem to care. Jack implicitly took some credit for getting the gifts, even though he did not contribute to the gifts, which is why he took the blame. Now, Jack has to figure out how to solve the problem.
Steps 2 & 3: Define the stakeholders and assess their motivations
- Jack:
- Personal: Jack believes the kids who did not get gifts need to be compensated better, unlike the staff; wants to maintain amiable relationships with the kids and staff, wants to do something for the kids
- Professional: wants to continue his social work at the youth center, does not want to upset the staff nor the children, wants to save face
- The four children who did not receive presents:
- Personal: Unhappy with their gifts, they believe Jack is to blame for this. They may be made fun of for not getting a gift, although it was an accident. They want to be included.
- Professional: Children do not have professional motivations
- The children who received presents:
- Personal: Happy to get a good gift, they believe Jack is a great person for “getting them” their gift
- Professional: Children do not have professional motivations
- The Staff
- Personal: Trying to save face by keeping blame on Jack. Many of the staff members grew up in the center themselves so they have personal ties to the center/families.
- Professional: wanting their next paycheck, getting their job done every day. They do not want Jack to get out of control with his savior complex and they want to work within their limits.
Step 4: Formulate (at least three) alternative solutions – based on information available, using basic ethical core values as guide
- Potential solution 1: Have a private (calm) discussion with the staff members involved being honest in a respectful manner. Kindly remind them what the big goal is, (the kids), and the best way to go about things
- Ethical Principle or code
- Fidelity and Responsibility, Justice, Respect for Persons and Dignity
- Pros
- Private setting and calm environment allow for civilized, honest discussion
- Hopefully will allow for a diplomatic, calm resolution
- Stern reminder of nature of venture and that tension will only impede that goal
- Cons
- Invitation to a private conversation could be seen as threatening
- The kids still may not understand the problem and may still be upset
- This does not directly help the fact that four kids did not get gifts and will feel neglected.
- Ethical Principle or code
Implications on relationships/venture:
-
-
-
- Short Term: Hopefully this will result in less tension between the staff and Jack and the children and Jack. This would be a good move for the youth center overall, but may be frowned upon in the short term.
- Long Term: This conversation will hopefully lead to a long term solution that will satisfy all parties involved. Everyone’s voice can be heard in this discussion.
-
-
- Reach out to a donor organization like WHO and see if they can get gifts for the students
-
- Pros:
- Jack would not have to pay for the gifts
- The kids would receive gifts
- The integrity of the youth center can be as Jack can save face, and the kids would no longer blame Jack
- Cons:
- The gifts may not be personalized for the kids
- It would take time for the kids to receive the gifts
- The four gifts are not that costly. The organization may not uphold this request because of the lack of relevance and cost.
- Implications on relationships/venture:
- Short Term: Jack’s relationship with the staff may be tarnished due to his extreme efforts to get the children gifts. This would also be extra work for the donor organization which they may be unhappy about. However, everyone saves face overall
- Long Term: In the long term, Jack solved a small problem for the youth center, and the staff will end up being grateful.
- Pros:
- Potential solution 3: Jack can purchase four presents on his own for the four children who were left out
- Pros:
- The children will get their presents
- The children will continue their positive relationship with Jack
- Cons:
- The children will not receive the same public receiving of the gifts like the other kids.
- Jack has to pay out of his own pocket for the toys, which is a con for Jack
- The other kids might see this as special treatment
- The staff might feel uncomfortable if Jack does not tell them, feel as if he is taking matters into his own hands.
- Implications on relationships/ venture:
- Short Term: Kids will be happy they got gifts. Jack helps the youth center save face by fixing the problem. He will also not receive the blame anymore.
- Long Term: Youth staff might appreciate Jack more for helping solve the problem, but this is not guaranteed, Jack saves his own face and the kids end up liking him more. The kids who did not receive presents will no longer feel excluded.
- Pros:
Step 5: Seek additional assistance, as appropriate – engineering codes of ethics, previous cases, peers, reliance on personal experience, inner reflection
- Ethics Principles (autonomy, non-maleficence, beneficence, justice, and fidelity)
- The kids without presents are being unjustly treated in comparison
- The Engineering Code of Ethics does not apply here
- Inner Reflection: If I put myself in a kid’s shoes, I know that I would feel excluded if I did not receive a gift. I would feel as if I did something wrong.
- Golden Rule: Treat others the way you want to be treated. As an extension of Inner Reflection, you would feel neglected if you were one of few who did not receive a gift
Step 6: Select the best course of action – that which satisfies the highest core ethical values.
Best Solution: Combination of 1 and 2 or 3. The staff and children should be explained of the problem, and should have an open conversation about the solution. Jack can purchase the four gifts himself, or a donor organization could pay for the gifts. This is the long term goal. In the short term, Jack can wear the black hat in order to make the four kids feel included in a group.
This is the best solution (ethically and tangibly) because:
- Kids that were neglected are given both an explanation and a comparable gift (Justice, Respect for Persons and Dignity). This means that they obtain a valuable learning experience and will eventually receive a gift.
- The stakeholder relationship with the staff is re-established and tension is diplomatically resolved (Fidelity and Responsibility)
- A long term solution, not just a band aid fix
- All stakeholders are satisfied, able to apologize and explain while allowing stakeholders to save face
Some Consequences may entail;
- It may be incredibly difficult to get in contact with an organization who would donate toys to Kenya or even for Jack to get toys himself of the center is remote and far away from anywhere that would sell toys (However, in this case, he could make toys out of wood)
- Depending on the cost of the gifts, Jack may have to pay a significant amount out of pocket.
- The ROI may not be worth it if using the donor funding route
- The social impact of getting toys for the kids would be positive. The economic and environmental impact variable is negligible.
Step 7: List the sequence of actions you will take to implement your solution.
- Find another donation center or pay out of pocket for 4 comparable gifts
- Give to 4 children and explain that no one was meant to get hurt, it was an honest mistake and all parties are sorry while giving them some sort of public recognition without it seeming forced or special.
- Mention the resolved situation and outcome to the staff members and have a diplomatic conversation to settle tensions and create a better understanding for the future
- With these steps, all stakeholders have a clear understanding of the situation and next steps to solve the problem if it were to happen again.
Looking for quality mental health treatment in Los Angeles? Turn to Casarecovery for comprehensive care and support. Our team of professionals is committed to helping you achieve mental wellness and a higher quality of life. Contact us today to get started on your path to healing
We offer outpatient treatment in Orange County for mental health disorders treatment. Learn more and get in touch with our team!
PTSD treatment orange county
https://my.talladega.edu/ICS/Academics/BUS/BUS__368/2015_SP-BUS__368-FT/Gradebook.jnz?portlet=Gradebook&screen=ViewStudentDetail&screenType=next&StudentID=620fe53f-77c7-4a62-bae0-b0dbf8fb1f00
Seeking privacy and discretion in your recovery journey? Capocanyon offers private rehab in Orange County. With our confidential and personalized approach, you can focus on your recovery in a comfortable and supportive environment. Reach out to us today for private rehab options.
Looking for your dream home in Los Angeles? Explore a wide range of homes for sale with The Knight Group LA. From cozy condos to luxurious estates, we have listings to suit every lifestyle and budget. Start your home search today! homes for sale los angeles
Transform your outdoor space with top-notch landscaping services in Dallas! At Lawns of Dallas, we specialize in creating beautiful and functional landscapes tailored to your needs. From design to maintenance, we’ve got you covered. Contact us today to elevate your outdoor living experience!
Searching for a talented landscape designer in Los Angeles? Look no further! At Elevated Seasons, we specialize in creating personalized outdoor spaces that reflect your style and vision. Our experienced designers will bring creativity and expertise to your project. Contact us now to collaborate on your dream landscape!
In need of safe and supportive drug detox in Orange County? At Capocanyon, we provide personalized detox programs to help you break free from substance dependence. Our experienced staff will guide you through the detox process with care and compassion. Reach out to us now to begin your detoxification journey.
Seeking effective addiction therapy? Our sessions provide personalized support and guidance to help you overcome challenges and achieve lasting sobriety.
Calling all thrill-seekers! Become a heli skier and conquer untouched terrain from dizzying heights. Our experienced guides will ensure a safe and exhilarating experience. Start your heli-ski journey with us today!
The American Sportfishing Association (ASFA) is a pivotal organization dedicated to promoting and of the sportfishing community. ASFA works tirelessly to protect fisheries and aquatic habitats, advocate for sound fisheries management policies, and ensure angler access to public waters https://www.americansportandfitness.com/
The American Sportfishing Association (ASFA) is a pivotal organization dedicated to promoting and preserving the interests of the sportfishing community. ASFA works tirelessly to and aquatic habitats, advocate for sound fisheries management policies, and ensure angler access to public waters https://www.americansportandfitness.com/
The content you create has always caught my attention.
실시간경마사이트
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this,
실시간 바카라사이트
Heliskiing is the perfect blend of luxury and extreme sport, offering exclusive access to some of the world’s best backcountry skiing. Ideal for those looking to elevate their skiing experience.
If you’re looking to transform your outdoor space, landscaping services in Los Angeles offer innovative solutions to create beautiful and functional gardens. Highly recommend them for any project!
A rollator walker provides excellent support and flexibility for those with mobility challenges. Its design includes comfortable seating and easy maneuverability, making daily activities much simpler.
A shower chair offers stability and ease for anyone with limited mobility. It’s a practical addition to any bathroom, ensuring a safer and more comfortable shower experience.
Usually there are some dissertation sites making use of the website whenever you develop into in plain english reported in the site. 카지노 추천 사이트
Navigating property tax in Dallas can be challenging, but understanding the local tax laws and assessment procedures can save you money and ensure you’re paying the correct amount.
The ethical dilemma arises from the unequal power dynamics and Jack’s status as a guest. His actions could inadvertently reinforce hierarchies or inadvertently marginalize some children. Jack needs to balance cultural sensitivity, respect for local customs, and ensuring fair treatment for all recipients. POD SALT Nexus
Innovation distinguishes between a leader and a follower. nhà cái uy tín
The more that you read, the more things you will know. The more that you learn, the more places you’ll go. new 88
The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall. 123win
Know that there is something inside you that is greater than any obstacle. king88
Education is the passport to the future, for tomorrow belongs to those who prepare for it today. 78win
It’s unfortunate to hear about the incident with the hats at the gift distribution. The way children were treated differently, receiving their hats less ceremoniously, understandably upset them. It’s crucial for all kids to feel included and valued, especially during such events. Juul Dubai
It’s great that Jack discussed this with the staff, highlighting the importance of fairness and sensitivity in these situations. Such empathy and communication can help prevent similar misunderstandings and ensure all children feel equally valued in future events. vape shops near me
https://888bz.vip/ Thanks for watching
Thanks for watching https://vin777.fan/
The examples below is definetly for instance glimmer brilliant. Each one of these insignificant issues are built utilizing wide variety of cornerstone knowledge. I spend time these folks a great deal. 仮想通貨 カジノ 入金ボーナス
Thank you for the valuable information mentioned in the blog! It has been incredibly helpful and informative. I appreciate the insights shared and look forward to more such content. Thanks again for your effort and time in putting this together! Slot Malaysia
This could be the appropriate blog for hopes to check out this topic. You already know a great deal its almost tricky to argue with you (not that When i would want…HaHa). You definitely put a fresh spin using a topic thats been discussing for many years. Wonderful stuff, just fantastic! Iptv uk
That are unquestionably superb. The majority of tiny specs are fashioned owning lot of track record competence. I’m just seeking to it again quite a lot. ブックメーカー サッカ
This amazing is very much unquestionably great. All these smaller fact is manufactured working with number with credentials know-how. I actually enjoy the reasoning the best value. オンラインカジノ 税金
At the bottom of the gift boxes were a few black hats. The kids who didn’t receive a present were given these hats, but they were upset because the distribution was not as ceremonious as for the others. The staff handed them the hats and dismissed them, as if the children were at fault. disposable vape dubai
He’s always been a happy-go-lucky kind of guy. i9bet
jun88 Thank you for sharing your info. I’m so grateful for everything you’ve done.
He was quaking in his boots before the job interview. Nhà cái ww88
Don’t worry, every cloud has a silver lining. OK VIP
Attractive, post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to say that I have liked browsing your blog posts. After all, I will surely subscribe to your feed, and I hope you will write again soon! 카지노 사이트 대한민국
Effective PTSD treatment in Orange County provides specialized care to help individuals manage and overcome their symptoms. Many local centers offer personalized programs tailored to each patient’s needs.
Luxury rehab in California provides top-tier amenities and high-quality care, ensuring a comfortable and effective recovery process. Perfect for those looking for a premium treatment experience.
Despite his age, he’s as fit as a fiddle. Giới thiệu 789BET
Thank you for posting information. Have a nice day! 안전놀이터
It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. 홀짝게임
This is a wonderful article. 홀짝게임
She tried her best, but her performance just didn’t cut the mustard. Mơ thấy máu
Stop pulling my leg; I know you’re joking. kuwin pink
We hope for the best but prepare for the worst in case things go wrong. kubet